Based on our overall comparison score, Apple MacBook Pro M5 Max rates higher at 70/100 versus 57/100 for Apple MacBook Air M4 15 — a 13-point lead. Apple MacBook Pro M5 Max is the stronger overall pick, though the right choice still depends on which specs matter most to you; the full spec table above breaks down every difference.
Apple MacBook Pro M5 Max vs Apple MacBook Air M4 15
Verdict
Our overall take, at a glance
Key takeaways
- Apple MacBook Pro M5 Max and Apple MacBook Air M4 15 are closely matched overall (within 4 points).
- Apple MacBook Pro M5 Max stands out on Memory capacity: 128 GB, Storage capacity: 8,192 GB, Display resolution: 3024 × 1964 px.
- Apple MacBook Air M4 15 counters with Memory Technology: Unified, Display Size: 15.3 in, Webcam resolution: 2880 × 1864 px.
- Best value: Apple MacBook Air M4 15 (from $1,199) — the strongest score-per-dollar of the two.
Apple MacBook Pro M5 Max and Apple MacBook Air M4 15 are closely matched
Apple MacBook Pro M5 Max
62
Apple MacBook Air M4 15
58
Where Apple MacBook Pro M5 Max stands out
- Memory capacity: 128 GB
- Storage capacity: 8,192 GB
- Display resolution: 3024 × 1964 px
Where Apple MacBook Air M4 15 stands out
- Memory Technology: Unified
- Display Size: 15.3 in
- Webcam resolution: 2880 × 1864 px
In-depth analysisAI
AI-generated from the cited sources — may be incomplete or inaccurate; verify important details before deciding · generated Jun 2026.
Apple MacBook Pro M5 Max
AI analysis isn't ready yet
We haven't generated an in-depth write-up for Apple MacBook Pro M5 Max yet. The specs, scores and strengths profile above still cover it — check back later for the AI summary.
Apple MacBook Air M4 15
The Apple MacBook Air M4 15 is a thin-and-light subnotebook designed for users seeking a large-screen portable experience without the bulk of a professional-grade machine. Powered by the Apple M4 system-on-a-chip, it features a 15.3-inch Liquid Retina display and a completely passive, fanless cooling system.
Best for Students and professionals who prioritize a large display and silent operationBest for Light creative tasks like on-the-go photo and video editing without the weight o
Pros
- Completely silent operation thanks to its fanless design
- Spacious 15.3-inch Liquid Retina display offers ample screen real estate
- Improved performance-to-cost ratio with a more competitive starting price
- Excellent battery life and responsiveness for daily multitasking
Cons
- Limited selection of built-in ports compared to the MacBook Pro line
- Absence of an active cooling fan can lead to thermal throttling during sustained, heavy processing tasks
Value for Money
Which is the better deal for the price
Pre-filled with launch prices where known — enter today's price for an up-to-date check. Use the same currency for both.
Apple MacBook Pro M5 Max
Apple MacBook Air M4 15
Battery capacity
Larger cell — a hardware spec, not battery life
Apple MacBook Pro M5 Max72.4 Wh
Apple MacBook Air M4 1566 Wh
Capacity is the raw battery size. Real-world battery life depends just as much on the processor, software and display.
Physical Comparison
Weigh them up, then compare real dimensions in 3D
Apple MacBook Pro M5 MaxApple MacBook Air M4 15
Apple MacBook Pro M5 Max is 0.11 kg (7%) heavier than Apple MacBook Air M4 15.
Review Videos
Hand-picked expert reviews for each product
Detailed Specifications
The full spec sheet, side by side
Frequently Asked Questions
Common questions about Apple MacBook Pro M5 Max vs Apple MacBook Air M4 15 comparison
Apple MacBook Pro M5 Max and Apple MacBook Air M4 15 are compared side by side above across every spec in the laptops category — including performance, features and design — each scored 0–100 so you can see exactly where one leads the other. Our overall scores are 70/100 for Apple MacBook Pro M5 Max and 57/100 for Apple MacBook Air M4 15.
At launch, Apple MacBook Air M4 15 was the more affordable option ($1199) versus Apple MacBook Pro M5 Max ($3599). Weigh that against the overall scores (70/100 vs 57/100) and the value-for-money meter above to judge whether the higher-rated model justifies its price for your needs. Current retail prices vary — check the retailer.
If you want the higher-rated laptops option overall, Apple MacBook Pro M5 Max (70/100) edges out Apple MacBook Air M4 15 (57/100). But if Apple MacBook Air M4 15 is cheaper or stronger on the specific specs you care about, it can still be the better buy — use the spec table and strengths profile above to decide.